A reference work on India's founding story
The Independence Myth
What actually ended British rule in India, why the story we were told was needed, and why it can end now.
The story is not what happened
India was taught to remember its independence as a favour, asked for politely and granted graciously. In fact Britain lost control of the army it ruled through, and that forced it out. The victory was real. Those who won it were written out.
The story was needed, and it worked
A new country of many languages and faiths needed one shared founding story to hold together. This one did that job. It can now be put down.
Primary sources
In their own words
Quoted exactly, with the source for every line.
Gandhi
A soldier who disobeys an order to fire breaks the oath which he has taken and renders himself guilty of criminal disobedience. I cannot ask officials and soldiers to disobey, for when I am in power I shall in all likelihood make use of those same officials and those same soldiers.
Gandhi
If they mutinied for the freedom of India they were doubly wrong. They could not do so without a call from a prepared revolutionary party. They were thoughtless and ignorant if they believed that by their might, they would deliver India from foreign domination.
Hitler
But Indian risings will never bring this about. We Germans have had sufficient experience to know how hard it is to coerce England. And, apart from all this, I as a German would far rather see India under British domination than under that of any other nation.
Churchill
At the Atlantic meeting, we had in mind, primarily, the restoration of the sovereignty, self-government and national life […] of the States and nations of Europe now under the Nazi yoke
12 chapters
The Argument
What actually ended British rule, and why the founding myth was needed.
Part I · The claim
Part II · The record
- 1942: The Movement That Was Crushed
- Bose and the Azad Hind Fauj
- The Red Fort Trials
- February 1946: The Mutinies
Part III · The argument
Part IV · Credit where it is due
Part V · Growing out of it
16 chapters
The Contradictions
Facts the official story cannot explain. Each one is a question the textbook account leaves unanswered.
Part I · Who the empire honours
Part II · The forces that did not change hands
Part III · The state that did not change hands
Part IV · How the record was managed
Part V · The arrangement
19 chapters
Gandhi: The Record
What Gandhi did, set out in his own words and quoted in full: the credit he deserves, the lives he offered, the revolts he restrained.
Part I · How to read this record
Part II · Indian lives, offered and spent
- The Ambulance Corps
- The Recruiting Campaign, 1918
- What Britain Gave Back
- Hitler Preferred British Rule
- The Atlantic Charter
- Bose in Germany
- The Cost of Offered Lives
Part III · Revolts restrained
Part IV · The ideas
Part V · The man and the myth
17 chapters
The Legacy
What it still costs to keep crediting the myth, and why that legacy has to die.
Part I · The cost of credit
Part II · The ideas it exported
- Poverty as Virtue
- Against the Machine
- Suspicion of Wealth
- Suffering as Proof
- Non-Violence as a Ban on Strength
- The Saint-Leader
- The Petitioner
- Intentions Over Results
- Caste and Paternalism
- The Body and Shame
Part III · Where it lives now
Part IV · Letting it die
17 chapters
The Inheritance
What the colonial state left behind that still runs India today: in its police, its laws, its offices and its habits of mind.