The Independence Myth

A reference work on India's founding story

The Independence Myth

What actually ended British rule in India, why the story we were told was needed, and why it can end now.

1

The story is not what happened

India was taught to remember its independence as a favour, asked for politely and granted graciously. In fact Britain lost control of the army it ruled through, and that forced it out. The victory was real. Those who won it were written out.

2

The story was needed, and it worked

A new country of many languages and faiths needed one shared founding story to hold together. This one did that job. It can now be put down.

Primary sources

In their own words

Quoted exactly, with the source for every line.

Gandhi

A soldier who disobeys an order to fire breaks the oath which he has taken and renders himself guilty of criminal disobedience. I cannot ask officials and soldiers to disobey, for when I am in power I shall in all likelihood make use of those same officials and those same soldiers.

Asked: “Why did you not see that the Garhwali soldiers, who had refused to fire on an unarmed crowd, were included in the truce?”Interview with Charles Petrasch, London, 1931. The Labour Monthly, vol. 14, no. 4, April 1932, pp. 217–224, reprinted from Monde, February 1932.Read it in context →

Gandhi

If they mutinied for the freedom of India they were doubly wrong. They could not do so without a call from a prepared revolutionary party. They were thoughtless and ignorant if they believed that by their might, they would deliver India from foreign domination.

On the sailors of the Royal Indian Navy, after their surrender.Press statement, Poona, 26 February 1946. Harijan, 3 March 1946; reprinted in My Non-violence (Navajivan, 1960), ch. 82.Read it in context →

Hitler

But Indian risings will never bring this about. We Germans have had sufficient experience to know how hard it is to coerce England. And, apart from all this, I as a German would far rather see India under British domination than under that of any other nation.

On Indian hopes that the British Empire would collapse in India.Mein Kampf, trans. James Murphy (London: Hurst and Blackett, 1939), vol. II, ch. XIV, “Germany’s Policy in Eastern Europe”.Read it in context →

Churchill

At the Atlantic meeting, we had in mind, primarily, the restoration of the sovereignty, self-government and national life […] of the States and nations of Europe now under the Nazi yoke

Explaining to Parliament that the Atlantic Charter did not apply to India.House of Commons, 9 September 1941. Hansard, vol. 374, cols. 68–69.Read it in context →

12 chapters

The Argument

What actually ended British rule, and why the founding myth was needed.

Part I · The claim

  1. The Premise

Part II · The record

  1. 1942: The Movement That Was Crushed
  2. Bose and the Azad Hind Fauj
  3. The Red Fort Trials
  4. February 1946: The Mutinies

Part III · The argument

  1. Why Britain Actually Left
  2. What 15 August Actually Was

Part IV · Credit where it is due

  1. The Myth That Built a Nation
  2. How Nations Are Held Together
  3. The Nations That Had No Myth

Part V · Growing out of it

  1. The Strongest Objections
  2. Why the Myth Can End Now

16 chapters

The Contradictions

Facts the official story cannot explain. Each one is a question the textbook account leaves unanswered.

Part I · Who the empire honours

  1. The Statue in Parliament Square
  2. Which Enemies Get Statues
  3. The Memorial Britain Destroyed

Part II · The forces that did not change hands

  1. British Commanders After 1947
  2. Two Armies, British Generals
  3. The King's Representative

Part III · The state that did not change hands

  1. The Intelligence Bureau
  2. The Colonial Laws
  3. The Constitution's Colonial Frame

Part IV · How the record was managed

  1. The INA Veterans
  2. The Mutineers of 1946
  3. The Secret Files

Part V · The arrangement

  1. The Recruiting Sergeant
  2. Every Revolt Called Off
  3. The Leader the Empire Chose
  4. Credit for the Outcome

19 chapters

Gandhi: The Record

What Gandhi did, set out in his own words and quoted in full: the credit he deserves, the lives he offered, the revolts he restrained.

Part I · How to read this record

  1. How to Read This Record
  2. What Gandhi Deserves Credit For

Part II · Indian lives, offered and spent

  1. The Ambulance Corps
  2. The Recruiting Campaign, 1918
  3. What Britain Gave Back
  4. Hitler Preferred British Rule
  5. The Atlantic Charter
  6. Bose in Germany
  7. The Cost of Offered Lives

Part III · Revolts restrained

  1. Chauri Chaura, 1922
  2. The Garhwali Soldiers
  3. Bhagat Singh
  4. The Naval Mutiny, 1946

Part IV · The ideas

  1. Hind Swaraj
  2. Ambedkar and the Poona Pact
  3. Advice in the Face of Hitler

Part V · The man and the myth

  1. Sidelined, 1946–47
  2. The Making of the Mahatma
  3. History as It Was

17 chapters

The Inheritance

What the colonial state left behind that still runs India today: in its police, its laws, its offices and its habits of mind.

Part I · The handover

  1. The Unfinished Handover
  2. A State Built to Rule

Part II · Police and law

  1. The Police Act of 1861
  2. The Thana
  3. Laws of Control
  4. The Courts

Part III · The administration

  1. The Collector
  2. The Steel Frame
  3. The Permission Raj
  4. VIP Culture

Part IV · The mind

  1. English as Gatekeeper
  2. The Babu Mindset
  3. Sahib and Servant
  4. The White-Skin Premium
  5. Divide and Rule

Part V · Undoing it

  1. What Has Changed
  2. A State for Citizens