16 contradictions
The Contradictions
Facts the official story cannot explain. Each one is set out the same way: what the story says, what the record shows, and the question that leaves.
How to read this section
None of these facts is secret. Each is a matter of record. Taken one at a time, each can be explained away. Taken together, they ask whether the empire was defeated at all, or whether it handed over power on terms it chose.
This section asks questions instead of making accusations. Read each one and decide whether the official story answers it.
Part I · Who the empire honours
-
The Statue in Parliament Square
Why does a former empire honour the man it says defeated it?
-
Which Enemies Get Statues
Which opponents does a former empire find acceptable to honour, and why are none of them the ones who took up arms against it?
-
The Memorial Britain Destroyed
Why destroy the memorial of an army that supposedly did not matter?
Part II · The forces that did not change hands
-
British Commanders After 1947
What kind of independence leaves the armed forces under the old ruler's officers for up to eleven more years?
-
Two Armies, British Generals
Who was really in command of the first war the two new nations fought?
-
The King's Representative
Free from whom, if the British king was still head of state?
Part III · The state that did not change hands
-
The Intelligence Bureau
Why did independent India's own government spend twenty years watching the family of the man the story leaves out?
-
The Colonial Laws
If the struggle was against colonial rule, why were the laws of colonial rule kept?
-
The Constitution's Colonial Frame
How much of the new state was built on the old one's design?
Part IV · How the record was managed
-
The INA Veterans
Why did the free nation refuse the soldiers who had fought for it?
-
The Mutineers of 1946
Why were the men who frightened the empire most left out of the free nation's navy?
-
The Secret Files
What in those files needed to be kept secret, and from whom?
Part V · The arrangement
-
The Recruiting Sergeant
If he cared about India's people first, why offer Indian lives for the empire's war?
-
Every Revolt Called Off
Whose interest did it serve to stop every revolt that threatened British rule?
-
The Leader the Empire Chose
Did the empire choose which Indian would speak for India?
-
Credit for the Outcome
How did the man who kept calling off the revolt come to be credited with the result?