The Independence Myth

Gandhi: The Record / Part III · Revolts restrained

The Naval Mutiny, 1946

Gandhi's two statements on the sailors who rose against British command.

1 min read

The first statement

This mutiny in the Navy and what is following is not, in any sense of the term, non-violent, action. […] Why should they continue to serve if service is humiliating for them or India? […] As it is, they are setting a bad and unbecoming example for India. A combination between Hindus and Muslims and others for the purpose of violent action is unholy and will lead to and probably is a preparation for mutual violence - bad for India and the world. The rulers have declared their intention to ‘quit’ in favour of Indian rule. […]

Press statement, Poona, 23 February 1946. Harijan, 3 March 1946; reprinted in My Non-violence (Navajivan, 1960), ch. 82. […] marks sentences left out here; read the full statement at the source. SourceChecked against the source text

The second statement

It is a matter of great relief that the ratings have listened to Sardar Patel’s advice to surrender. They have not surrendered their honour. So far as I can see, in resorting to mutiny they were badly advised. […] If they mutinied for the freedom of India they were doubly wrong. They could not do so without a call from a prepared revolutionary party. They were thoughtless and ignorant if they believed that by their might, they would deliver India from foreign domination.

Press statement, Poona, 26 February 1946, replying to Aruna Asaf Ali. Harijan, 3 March 1946; reprinted in My Non-violence (Navajivan, 1960), ch. 82. […] marks a sentence left out here. SourceChecked against the source text

What they show